Illinois Voters Push Back on Data Centers as Courts Uphold Local Approvals

In the November 2026 election, voters across Illinois voiced their opposition to data center development in a series of advisory referenda. Meanwhile, two Illinois courts issued some of the state’s first rulings rejecting legal challenges to county data center permits.

On

Both developments point to how local permits can shape development, with the election results illustrating that local permits may be harder to secure. Pressure is also building on county boards and city councils to impose moratoria, tighten siting conditions, and address ratepayer costs. Meanwhile, the courts are signaling that once a permit issues, it is hard to undo. 

That tension, between voters pushing for a harder front end and courts treating an issued permit as durable, will define the next phase of data center development in Illinois. The contrast is stark in Joliet, where 79% of voters supported a moratorium, even as a court upheld the city’s annexation and rezoning for a roughly 795-acre data center campus.

For developers, that shifts risk toward the period before approval. Community opposition increasingly matters because it may determine whether a permit issues at all, not because an issued permit is necessarily easy to overturn.

Voters Sent a Clear Message on Data Centers

Across Illinois, voters overwhelmingly supported nonbinding referenda against data center development. In Bloomington, an advisory moratorium on large-scale data centers received 77% of the vote. In Joliet, 79% of voters advised against artificial intelligence data centers. In four Madison County townships, anti-data-center referenda passed by similar margins. In Morgan County, 88% of voters told the county to adopt data center restrictions.The results were similar in both urban and small-town counties in different regions of the state. 

Although these votes are only advisory, the decisiveness of the margins will likely shape how local officials act. The likeliest tools are moratoria, special or conditional use permits, and standards addressing electricity and water demand. Communities may also adopt data-center-specific zoning classifications or add standards on backup-generator emissions, noise, setbacks, decommissioning, and community benefits. Developers may want to start community engagement before the application, not at the hearing.

Illinois is rethinking its approach to data centers at the state level, too. In 2019, the General Assembly created the Data Center Investment Program, which offers qualifying data centers sales and use tax exemptions for up to 20 years. More recently, the state has turned its attention to the costs. Citing concerns including rising utility bills, Governor JB Pritzker directed the Department of Commerce and Economic Opportunity to stop processing new program applications as of July 1. Agreements entered into before that date will be honored. The governor has also urged lawmakers to pass the POWER Act, which would add water, energy, and community-benefit requirements for data centers. 

Illinois Courts Rejected Procedural and Substantive Challenges to Data Center Approvals

In two decisions, Illinois courts in suburban Will County and central Sangamon County rejected claims challenging data center permits. On October 19, the Will County circuit court ruled for the developer in Joliet Residents for Responsible Growth v. City of Joliet, a case challenging Joliet’s annexation and rezoning for a roughly 795-acre hyperscale data center campus.

The court rejected three procedural challenges. It held that the hearing notice substantially complied with applicable statutes, that the relevant meeting was open to the public, and that the plaintiffs received procedural due process. The court also held that the plaintiffs did not plead a specific enough injury to support standing on their substantive due process claim. It dismissed that claim but granted the plaintiffs an opportunity to amend their complaint.

On November 6, the Sangamon County circuit court dismissed a challenge to the Sangamon County Board’s approval of a conditional use permit for a data center proposed on approximately 280 acres of farmland. In Caruthers v. County of Sangamon, neighboring farmers, livestock operators, homeowners, and a kennel owner alleged that industrial noise, generator emissions, water demand, and property-value impacts would harm their properties and businesses.

The court applied rational basis review. Under that standard, the court explained, the board’s action “is highly presumed to be valid and creates an exceptionally difficult hurdle for the Plaintiffs to overcome.” The court’s review was “limited to only whether a conceivable rational relationship exists between the decision and a legitimate governmental purpose.” 

The court found the county board had a rational basis to approve the project. It ruled that “job creation, economic investment, limited environmental effects, infrastructure benefits, and projected tax revenue” formed a basis for the approval. 

Two Decisions, Two Separate Hurdles for Challengers

The decisions addressed different types of siting challenges. Joliet Residents largely concerned procedural issues, such as the adequacy of notice. Caruthers addresses the concerns to the substance of the local government’s land-use decision and the deference owed to it. 

For local governments and developers, the cases underscore the value of building an effective record throughout the approval process. Get the notice and procedure right and build a substantive record that ties the approval to concrete benefits such as tax revenue, employment, infrastructure, environmental mitigation, and community investment. The practical lesson: win the record at the permit stage because that is where these cases are likely to be decided. 

Implications for Data Centers, Battery Storage, and Renewable Energy Siting in Illinois

The referenda signal that communities can be hostile to development, particularly where residents expect noise, strain on the grid, or higher electricity bills. Meanwhile, the two court rulings suggest that Illinois courts reviewing data center approvals and other controversial projects may give substantial deference to applicants and boards that build a record of the project’s benefits. Two circuit court orders are not binding precedent, but they show how courts are approaching these disputes.

Wind, solar, and battery projects can face similar objections. Unlike data centers, those projects are governed by Illinois’ statewide county siting standards. Still, once a county or municipality issues a permit, these projects may also face lawsuits from community members who oppose them. At that point, the Joliet Residents and Caruthers decisions may provide persuasive precedent. 

Contacts

Continue Reading