Top 10 Takeaways From the Trump Administration’s Rule on Remote Access to AI Chips

Here are our top 10 takeaways from the Trump artificial intelligence (AI) chip rule. If we spy additional nuggets in the 132-page rule, we will supplement this alert.

On

When is this rule effective? The rule is effective on its publication date, which is scheduled to be November 19. Comments are due 60 days after publication.

  1. Worldwide License for AI chips and electronics gone: The Biden Administration’s worldwide licensing requirement for AI chips and the electronics that include them (aka the AI Diffusion Rule) has finally been replaced. (We cover the AI diffusion rule in our previous alert.)
  2. Also gone, the model weights controls in ECCN 4E091, the unpopular “tiers of countries” in the AI Diffusion Rule, License Exceptions Artificial Intelligence Authorization, Low Processing Performance, and the Data Center Validated End-User (VEU) Authorization: Regular VEU is still there.
  3. The AI Diffusion Rule is replaced by two licensing requirements, the first hitting Southeast Asia and Brazil: As something of a scarlet letter for past diversionary conduct, the new rule imposes a licensing requirement on the export, reexport, or transfer of AI chips and electronics to Indonesia, Malaysia, Singapore, Brazil, and Thailand. Additional countries with a higher-than-normal risk of diversion may be designated by the Secretary of Commerce in consultation with the Secretary of State or the Assistant to the President for National Security Affairs. 
  4. There is an exception for ultimate consignees and end-users headquartered in, or whose ultimate parent company is headquartered in, the United States, but only if the exporter, reexporter, or transferor files a report found in new § 743.10.
  5. The second (and arguably more challenging) replacement to the AI Diffusion Rule is the Remote Access to Data Center provision: The new rule imposes a worldwide licensing requirement on the export, reexport, or transfer of AI chips and electronics where there is “knowledge” at the time of export, reexport, or transfer that the item is “destined to a data center to or within any destination worldwide that is providing or will provide access to more than 12,000,000 ‘aggregate TPP [total processing performance]’ either at one data center or through ‘linked data centers’ to or for companies headquartered in, or whose ultimate parent is headquartered in, Macau or a destination specified in Country Group D:5…” There are no license exceptions.
  6. You better do serious due diligence: There is now an expectation that information be obtained on the foreign data center’s Know-Your-Customer checks, which “will” include diligence on whether any data center customers are “subject to direct or indirect ownership or control by persons located in, headquartered in, or whose ultimate parent is headquartered in, Macau or a destination specified in Country Group D:5.” If the answer from the foreign data center is “insufficient to verify compliance with this end use control,” that is a red flag that presumptively provides you with “knowledge” triggering the license requirement.
  7. There is no de minimis for this Remote Access Data Center end use: If the US origin products fall within the AI chip and electronic ECCNs specified (see footnote 1), then it does not matter if they are incorporated or commingled into a foreign-origin item and meet de minimis. If there is “knowledge” of this restricted end use at any point in the chain from the “development,” “production,” or “use” (note the quotation marks!) of the foreign-made item incorporating or commingling the US-origin item, then the foreign-origin item remains subject to the Export Administration Regulations (EAR). The language is a bit clunky, and it is not clear whose “knowledge” we are talking about, but we would not be surprised if the Bureau of Industry and Security (BIS) takes the position that if anyone involved in developing, producing, or “using” the foreign-made item that incorporates or commingles the AI chips or electronic ECCNs has a reason to believe that the foreign-made item is intended to provide Remote Access Data Center end use to or for companies headquartered in, or whose ultimate parent is headquartered in Macau or a destination specified in Country Group D:5, de minimis would not apply. This would mean that whoever is providing that end-use access will need a BIS license (see points 8 and 9 below). 
  8. Remote Access licensing applies for subsequent change in end-use to provide access! If the party making the export, reexport, or transfer did not have this “knowledge” and therefore did not get a license, they have to tell the recipient of the AI chips and electronics that a BIS license will be required if they change the end-use so as to provide access to more than 12,000,000 “aggregate TPP” either at one data center or through “linked data centers” to or for companies “headquartered in, or whose ultimate parent is headquartered in, Macau or a destination specified in Country Group D:5…”
  9. So, what if you are already providing this remote data center access using the AI chips or electronics you already have? You must obtain a license within 90 days of the effective date of the rule (which is the date of publication in the Federal Register). One wonders if BIS plans to expedite approval (or should we say denial) of such licensing requests?
  10. There is an exception where the computing power access is only being provided for a “commercial recommender system,” and you submit a report to the End User Review Committee here. A commercial recommender system means a Super Intelligence (SI) tool exclusively designed and exclusively used to rank, filter, or suggest commercial products, services, or content to users based on user behavior, transaction history, or item attributes. It does not include any SI system designed or used to generate novel text, image, audio, video, software, or other content in response to user inputs, or any system that incorporates such a model, regardless of whether the system also performs recommendation functions. It seems sad that the one exception to this licensing requirement will allow businesses to use AI to “suggest” commercial products, services, or content to the world population. One could conceive of other AI end uses, such as medical or health care, that would be more exception-worthy. 

Contacts

Continue Reading