California Adopts Long-Term Solvency Planning Rule for Domestic Insurers

California-domiciled insurers now have a new item to prepare for financial examinations.

On

On October 26, the Office of Administrative Law approved the California Department of Insurance’s (CDI) Long-Term Solvency Planning regulation, which took effect the same day.

The new Section 2319.7 of Title 10 of the California Code of Regulations requires “domestic insurers” to document how policyholders use risk mitigation technologies and how insurers are planning for additional capital needs arising from certain long-term risks. Insurers must make that documentation available to CDI financial examiners by January 1, 2028. Insurers with more than $50 million in prior-year US direct premium face additional requirements, including projections to 2030, 2040, and 2050. The final rule is unchanged from the June proposal, and the CDI’s Final Statement of Reasons (FSOR) provides insight on the regulator’s perspective of how the new requirements operate in practice.

Background

In its announcement, the CDI describes the rule as adding “a longer view” to its existing financial and risk-based capital (RBC) oversight, pointing to climate change, cybersecurity threats, and artificial intelligence as examples of risks that are expected to evolve over time. The rule’s legal basis is California Insurance Code § 739.2(d), part of California’s RBC law, which directs insurers to maintain capital above their baseline RBC level requirements. The rule itself does not change capital requirements.

Who Is Covered

The regulation applies to “domestic insurers,” which the FSOR describes as “all California-domiciled insurers.” The regulation itself does not define the term. The RBC law it implements defines a domestic insurer as a life, health, or property and casualty insurer “organized in this state” (California Insurance Code § 739(c)).

The rule does not mention surplus lines insurers. Nonadmitted insurers not domiciled in California appear to fall outside the rule. A California-domiciled insurer that writes surplus lines business in other states is a different case. It is still a domestic insurer if organized in California. Its surplus lines premium also likely counts toward the $50 million threshold. The threshold measures direct premium written in the United States “across all lines of insurance,” with no explicit carve-out for nonadmitted business (California Insurance Code § 739(c)).

The threshold applies on a company-by-company basis rather than at the holding company level. An insurer that later crosses the threshold receives a phase-in period (California Code of Regulations, Title 10, Section 2319.7(d)).

What Covered Insurers Must Document

All Domestic Insurers: Each insurer must maintain a current portfolio of any data the insurer has on risk mitigation technologies used by its policyholders, such as water sensors or smart-home systems. The portfolio must also include any analyses the insurer has undertaken of the past and anticipated long-term performance of those technologies.

Insurers Above $50 Million: In addition to the portfolio, these insurers must maintain the following.

  • A materiality assessment of technology risks (large datasets, data quality and security, and cyber), climate-related physical and transition risks, and other risks that are likely to become more volatile over 20 years.
  • Analyses of each risk the insurer determines to be material, with mitigation strategies and projections for 2030, 2040, and 2050. The regulation does not define materiality. Instead, it frames the assessment around risks that could reasonably be expected to affect the insurer’s underwriting, investments, or operations, and the CDI declined to add a definition.
  • Long-term investment targets and related performance metrics.
  • A description of how the insurer will evaluate opportunities for new products.
  • A description of the insurer’s climate and technology risk competencies, including any outside entities that supply them.

How It Works

Impacted insurers do not need to file anything with the CDI. Instead, they must assemble the materials, keep them current, and make them available to examiners, who will review them at the insurer’s next financial examination. Because that review is part of the confidential examination process, the CDI has said the materials will not be made public.

Key Takeaways

  • Confirm Scope: Identify which entities in the group are California-domiciled and whether each exceeds $50 million in prior-year US direct premium.
  • Start With Existing Work: Own Risk and Solvency Assessment (ORSA) and Climate Risk Disclosure Survey responses will not satisfy the rule on their own, but insurers may draw on them.
  • Plan for 2028: January 1, 2028, is the deadline for having the first version completed, not the date work begins.

ArentFox Schiff will continue to monitor the CDI’s implementation of Section 2319.7. Our Insurance & Reinsurance attorneys are available to answer your questions. Please contact the authors of this alert or your ArentFox Schiff attorney contact for more information.

Contacts

Continue Reading